Thursday, April 21, 2016

Participation for today´s class

What can you tell me about the reading you had about "Edna Snell", what was the most important moment for you?, what happened? say something about it!

42 comments:

  1. Edna Snells was a woman who lost her "love of her life" during the first world war, so after that she was depressed, she didn't want to eat again, to live again. I think that maybe the most important moment was when we didn't accept that had to continue with her live, she had to get over it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, the reading is about Edna Snell, a woman who lost her fiance ´cause he was killed during the First World War, then she was so sad, and she refused to eat. I think, that the most important moment was when maybe she wanted to be with Billy, and finally she gave up, and die.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Edna Snells was a woman who was sad and depressed because losing her fiance in the First World War , because of her sadness , she stopped eating and did not want to follow his life . Accept that a person will not be with us is something Important in the life of each person and for she was the most importan moment in your life.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Edna Snells was a woman who was sad and depressed because losing her fiance in the First World War , because of her sadness , she stopped eating and did not want to follow his life . Accept that a person will not be with us is something Important in the life of each person and for she was the most importan moment in your life.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The story of Edna Snell is a love story; she was a lovely lady when she was 20 years old but in her heart she was forever young. When she was 105 years old she died, but she always loved Bill. For me the most important moment was when she died holding his photograph.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The heart of Edna Snell shattered whe Brill Smith the Man she planned to marry died in the first world wor Edna Snell lost the desire to eat, stayed with photograph that was in his unitorm whe he died, but did not lose the desire to he looking at her photograph Edna refused to eat she had given up and wanted to die all I wanted was to be with Billie aftet all these years of separation are finally together indeath.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think that the history of edna snell is so sad, because she lost the love of her life and then all the years she lived, she spend her the time always talking about him, and when she dies, when she died even thought about him.
    and the fragment that i love is this: -'' It's lovely to think that, after all those years spend apart, they are finally together in death''. <3

    ReplyDelete
  8. The story of Edna is beautiful and sad at the same time, it was very lovely girl who was always in love with the love of his life Billie.
    Always he talked about until she dies the only thing she wanted was to be ith the man of her life.
    The most importnt moment is ehn she dies, all he wanted was to be with him finally be together until eternity.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I feel that his story is very sad, for the aver lost her fiance in the First World War she falls into depression, it stops eating and did not want to get on with life . For me the most important mometo was when he dies but took with her the memory of Bill , the love of his life.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This love story is intense Edna and Bill she lost the love of his life in World War I that's pretty sad since dropped too stopped eating and went into depression, always thought of him. I think that sometimes you can not accept things because it is such an intense love even if it is moving forward always be tied to that feeling and the most beautiful moment was when he finally came close to Bill the love of his life.

    LIZBETH SANCHEZ SANTACRUZ

    ReplyDelete
  11. Edna's story is touching, at age 20 she was disappointed in life, losing her beloved Billie, with whom he intended to be married, in the First World War, also fell into abysmal depression that even in his last days life no more than the fact of having lost his beloved, and to remember always watched a photograph of Billie, lost to the desire to eat, but never want to see that picture that made him think of all the wonderful things they could do together, he died at age 105 years, but in the hope of seeing his beloved Billie in death.

    Javier Santacruz Salgado

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. For me the story of Edna is very sad love with reminiscent of Billie is really deep. An important event for me was when she resigned to daily and necessary actions themselves that lead directly to death, thinking the other people who would be a loving reunion with Billie, the love of his life who died during the First World War.
    The fact that Edna was depressed and no time to heal their wounds, seems to me an act of true love.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thank you for being punctual on the blog. Please share the information with your classmates. They should participate.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you for being punctual on the blog. Please share the information with your classmates. They should participate.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I personally think the story is somewhat dramatic as Edna refused to try to live after the death of her fiance Billie because of the Second World War. The moment I most thought it important is that despite the years, how young he was and the years that he lived, never fell in love again, I was able to be faithful to a person who was no longer physically with she.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Edna lost the love of his life during the second world war, so it became depressed. the poignant is that the unio death, but ended up together as she wanted.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I personally think the story is somewhat dramatic as Edna refused to try to live after the death of her fiance Billie because of the Second World War. The moment I most thought it important is that despite the years, how young he was and the years that he lived, never fell in love again, I was able to be faithful to a person who was no longer physically with she.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Edna lost the love of his life during the second world war, so it became depressed. the poignant is that the unio death, but ended up together as she wanted.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Snell Edna was a woman who went through a sad time to lose the " love of his life " who unfortunately died in World War II instead of that she refuses to eat and most importantly to live and follow the life and the past back and for my opinion there is nothing more beautiful than true love and experience it live

    ReplyDelete
  21. Snell Edna was a woman who went through a sad time to lose the " love of his life " who unfortunately died in World War II instead of that she refuses to eat and most importantly to live and follow the life and the past back and for my opinion there is nothing more beautiful than true love and experience it live

    ReplyDelete
  22. I found a very romantic story for the simple fact that Edna no longer wanted to continue with her life after her husband died because of World War I showed that his entire life revolved around her partner <3

    ReplyDelete
  23. edna history and billie is too beautiful and too too sad, Edna was a very beautiful girl who always thought about the love of his life that was billie . When he died she only spoke of the and said that until he died all he wanted was to be thinking about the man in her life

    ReplyDelete
  24. edna history and billie is too beautiful and too too sad, Edna was a very beautiful girl who always thought about the love of his life that was billie . When he died she only spoke of the and said that until he died all he wanted was to be thinking about the man in her life

    ReplyDelete
  25. snell in its history edna what happened is that he lost the love of his life all that time the depressed step.
    the most important moment is to overcome that lost the love of his life and that and it will cost.

    ReplyDelete
  26. The story tells of how Edna Snells was feeling , she was feeling nuy trizte and depressed by the loss of her fiance in the First World War , she no longer wanted to continue with his life.
    for her the most important thing in his life was and thinking that would not be more in his life became very depressed .
    by; JUAREZ PEREZ MAYRA JOSELINE

    ReplyDelete
  27. This story tells a sincere love of Edna and Billie and feelings that causes it to Edna death of his beloved , eventhough it is very sad to leave us a lesson of true love <3

    ReplyDelete
  28. Snells Edna was a woman who lost her "love of her life" during the First World War, so after she was depressed, did not want to eat, to live again.
    I personally think that the most difficult moment of his life was when she wanted to be with Billy, and finally gave up, and die.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Its a romantic history, Edna was a woman who lost her "Love of her life" during the First World War.


    My opinion is: Sincere love of Edna, its lealted.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Its a romantic history, Edna was a woman who lost her "Love of her life" during the First World War.


    My opinion is: Sincere love of Edna, its lealted.

    ReplyDelete
  31. The most important and hard to Edna moment in the Second World War, she loses the love of his life. And most salvageable and admiration is how she makes the decision to die or make a change in your life to get ahead.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I think a slightly sad and romantic story Edna snell was a girl of only 20 years old and very beautiful, Edna lost the love of his life in the first world war, which led her into depression and stop eating. The most poignant moment is when she dies and meets what I wanted to be with the again together in death, until eternity.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I think a slightly sad and romantic story Edna snell was a girl of only 20 years old and very beautiful, Edna lost the love of his life in the first world war, which led her into depression and stop eating. The most poignant moment is when she dies and meets what I wanted to be with the again together in death, until eternity.

    ReplyDelete
  34. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  35. My God! Edna really loved him! This is a really sad story that reminded me some movies, TV series and books I've read. I think she was loyal her whole life to "the love of her life" and I'm pretty sure I would do the same. Love is the greatest thing that we have in the world and maybe if my boyfriend would die (I hope no, he's too young) I would feel the same as Edna. Personally I've never met someone who has lived a similar experience, but, as I said before, I've seen cases like this in movies and series, so I admire when the woman (or in some cases the man) remains loyal to her lover.

    ReplyDelete
  36. she lost the love of his life during the First World War ... she loved him Verdas and although no longer wanted to eat and live as impoetante was followed with his life, I really liked really touching a beautiful story.
    A true love ♡

    ReplyDelete
  37. It is a beautiful history because it is the romance of Edna and Bill that originates during the first world war and tells us Edna feels sad because he does not find Bill

    ReplyDelete

  38. Edna was a girl who lived a tragedy , or rather a tragedy of love, because she was getting married , but could not do because her boyfriend died in the trenches of war. Her fiance was called Bill .By Omar Campillo Martínez

    ReplyDelete

  39. Edna was a girl who lived a tragedy , or rather a tragedy of love, because she was getting married , but could not do because her boyfriend died in the trenches of war. Her fiance was called Bill .By Omar Campillo Martínez

    ReplyDelete
  40. Edna Snelles was a woman who was sad and depressed because losing her fiance.an important event for me was when she resigned to daily and necessary actions
    when she wa 105 years old she died but she always love Bill.

    ReplyDelete
  41. edna snell was unamujerdeprimiva by that unfortunate event that marked the rest of his life

    ReplyDelete